Results

Overall statistics

The total amount of P2P loans in the sample was £378.3 million. In the data, the UK market from Oct 2010 to May 2013, we can identify 48,891 lenders and 59,851 recipients (see Methodology for details and caveats). Table 1.1 shows the average loan and Figure 1.1 and 1.2 the whole distribution across lenders and recipients.

The unit of analysis is a loan part. In total there are 13,924,547 loan parts. A recipient who takes out a loan of, for example, £5,000 may receive the money from hundreds of different lenders. Vice versa, a lender may subdivide her investment into many loans. A typical (median, see explanation) amount for a loan part is £10. However, in a small number of cases the investment per loan part is substantially larger.

Table 1.1 Descriptive statistics for lenders and recipients
Lender Recipient
Mean loan £7,737 £6,320
Median loan £1,290 £4,160
Standard deviation £29,369 £11,060

The table above speaks a clear language: lenders are much more skewed towards large loan amounts than recipients. The salient difference in mean and median loan values, as well as the large standard deviation, are a hint that a few lenders use large sums, whereas most recipients deal with amounts between £3,000 to £6,000. This result makes intuitive sense because lenders have more financial freedom than recipients and this is also reflected in the following box plots.

Figure 1.1 Box plot for loan amounts of lenders (logarithmic scale)
Figure 1.2 Box plot for loan amounts of recipients (logarithmic scale)
box plot lenders box plot recipients

Growth over time

The P2P market has been growing steadily since its early days. In particular, we can compare the number of lenders and recipients at the beginning of the period (end of 2010) with the end of period (May 2013). The following maps plot the individual postcodes of lenders and recipients. Notice how there are no country boundaries and the maps emerge entirely from the postcodes.

Map 1.1 Growth of lenders over time
Map 1.2 Growth of recipients over time
growth of lenders growth of recipients

Regional flows

Each loan part has a postcode for the lender and the recipient. Thus, we can calculate regional flows at any level in the UK. Table 1.2 is aggregated on a regional level. Perhaps not surprisingly, London is the biggest lender and the second biggest recipient. Only the South East receives more financial resources from the P2P market.

Four regions have a positive balance; they invest more than they receive. All four regions, London, South East, South West and the East of England lie in the South of the UK. We can also look at more detailed patterns (see Appendix). However, bear in mind that the regional allocation is, in most cases, not a deliberate decision because of the platforms' functionalities. This depends on the platform itself. There may occur regional allocations based on implicit selection such as the loan rate. Therefore the findings in the appendix allude more to the robust nature of the market than personal investment decisio)ns.

Table 1.2 Regional statistics and population figures (in £ and £ per person)
Region As lender As recipient Net sum Population Investment (£ p.p.) Receiving (£ p.p.) Net sum (£ p.p.)
London 96,535,000 48,725,000 47,810,000 8,204,000 11.8 5.9 5.8
South East 76,353,000 57,602,000 18,751,000 8,653,000 8.8 6.7 2.2
South West 41,144,000 32,076,000 9,068,000 5,301,000 7.8 6.1 1.7
East of England 37,243,000 29,748,000 7,495,000 5,862,000 6.4 5.1 1.3
West Midlands 21,207,000 29,978,000 -8,771,000 5,609,000 3.8 5.3 -1.6
East Midlands 15,665,000 25,239,000 -9,574,000 4,537,000 3.5 5.6 -2.1
North West 26,803,000 42,434,000 -15,631,000 7,056,000 3.8 6.0 -2.2
Yorkshire and The Humber 20,584,000 32,756,000 -12,172,000 5,288,000 3.9 6.2 -2.3
Northern Ireland 2,527,000 6,993,000 -4,466,000 1,807,000 1.4 3.9 -2.5
Scotland 19,219,000 33,108,000 -13,889,000 5,255,000 3.7 6.3 -2.6
Wales 12,880,000 22,355,000 -9,475,000 3,064,000 4.2 7.3 -3.1
North East 8,104,000 17,250,000 -9,146,000 2,596,000 3.1 6.6 -3.5

We included some external open data, namely population estimates from the UK census for each of the region. From this we can "normalise" (divide) the regional figures by population. London still tops the list with £12 per person of lending. The differences across regions are more pronounced among lenders. The range of lending per person ranges from £1.4 to £11.8 for UK regions, whereas the range for recipients only goes from £3.9 to £7.3 per person. Hence, there is substantially more lending in London and the South of the UK, whilst recipients are more evenly distributed across the country.

Loan rates and term per region

The UK has 12 regions and because a region can lend itself money there are a total of 144 possible combination for different flows. For each tuple, e.g. London lending to the South East, we calculated the average loan rate and average length (see weights for details).

In both cases, loan rates and term, we find that the variation between region is surprisingly low. On average loans are priced between 6.1% and 6.7% and have a length of 37 to 41 months.

There is no salient pattern for recipients when it comes to interest rates. The lowest rates for lenders, on the other hand, are all in the East of England. This fits with the fact that those loans are also slightly shorter compared to the rest of the UK.

Figure 1.3 Histogram of loan rates for each regional flow

histogram loan rates

Figure 1.4 Histogram of terms for each regional flow

histogram term

Counties

Similarly to regions, we can calculate statistics for English counties. Table 1.3 shows total amount for lenders and recipients for each English county. The net is calculated as the difference, i.e. lending - receiving. The visualisation on the front page provides further tools to explore the data.

Table 1.3 Loan amounts for English Counties (in £)
County Lending Receiving Net
Buckinghamshire 8,533,000 3,974,000 4,559,000
Cambridgeshire 7,557,000 3,569,000 3,988,000
Cumbria 3,504,000 3,532,000 -28,000
Derbyshire 2,877,000 5,046,000 -2,169,000
Devon 6,759,000 3,786,000 2,973,000
Dorset 3,628,000 1,955,000 1,673,000
East Sussex 3,915,000 3,222,000 693,000
Essex 10,802,000 8,587,000 2,215,000
Gloucestershire 5,171,000 4,569,000 602,000
Hampshire 12,041,000 9,255,000 2,786,000
Hertfordshire 11,686,000 8,230,000 3,456,000
Kent 9,891,000 8,687,000 1,204,000
Lancashire 6,346,000 8,549,000 -2,203,000
Leicestershire 3,409,000 5,191,000 -1,782,000
Lincolnshire 2,957,000 4,594,000 -1,637,000
Norfolk 5,436,000 4,870,000 566,000
North Yorkshire 4,176,000 3,983,000 193,000
Northamptonshire 3,463,000 5,018,000 -1,555,000
Nottinghamshire 2,810,000 6,056,000 -3,246,000
Oxfordshire 8,573,000 5,625,000 2,948,000
Somerset 3,196,000 2,939,000 257,000
Staffordshire 2,680,000 5,797,000 -3,117,000
Suffolk 4,071,000 4,331,000 -260,000
Surrey 16,169,000 8,819,000 7,350,000
Warwickshire 3,271,000 4,323,000 -1,052,000
West Sussex 6,903,000 5,879,000 1,024,000
Worcestershire 4,764,000 3,921,000 843,000

Appendix

All tables can be downloaded as a csv-file in the “Get the data” section.

Table A.1 Detailed regional flows within the UK
Recipient —> East Midlands East of England London North East North West Northern Ireland Scotland South East South West Wales West Midlands Yorkshire and The Humber Grand Total
East Midlands 1,082,239 1,253,465 1,931,601 717,833 1,734,419 313,874 1,382,597 2,345,638 1,358,018 942,027 1,253,462 1,350,242 15,665,415
East of England 2,540,988 3,017,567 4,882,314 1,694,655 4,176,652 717,684 3,265,778 5,571,834 3,144,042 2,179,792 2,906,871 3,144,891 37,243,068
London 6,459,724 7,583,354 12,715,278 4,441,576 10,746,336 1,779,919 8,368,098 14,754,875 8,026,654 5,752,434 7,598,439 8,308,033 96,534,720
North East 528,270 614,205 1,071,738 377,020 906,671 143,762 693,511 1,243,873 706,912 499,775 628,509 690,172 8,104,418
North West 1,773,710 2,111,984 3,452,080 1,215,997 3,034,572 534,488 2,364,109 4,192,762 2,198,661 1,528,435 2,074,845 2,321,100 26,802,743
Northern Ireland 167,270 209,193 320,520 112,201 282,502 50,969 214,199 378,503 210,116 155,717 207,733 217,744 2,526,667
Scotland 1,303,323 1,486,973 2,376,384 853,753 2,162,910 354,436 1,719,886 2,946,097 1,649,782 1,132,434 1,529,130 1,703,767 19,218,875
South East 4,995,008 6,017,186 9,704,289 3,501,018 8,535,475 1,390,057 6,752,562 11,621,726 6,602,483 4,471,171 6,026,293 6,735,416 76,352,684
South West 2,750,730 3,272,974 5,222,877 1,834,053 4,647,748 748,696 3,603,066 6,166,448 3,584,220 2,412,801 3,310,944 3,589,759 41,144,316
Wales 858,358 966,830 1,595,339 583,999 1,462,615 220,910 1,125,068 1,947,737 1,131,198 789,822 1,036,950 1,160,819 12,879,645
West Midlands 1,446,493 1,614,029 2,763,484 940,242 2,388,386 371,647 1,873,382 3,277,501 1,767,179 1,264,677 1,754,851 1,745,311 21,207,182
Yorkshire and The Humber 1,333,135 1,600,036 2,688,715 977,471 2,355,817 366,425 1,745,760 3,154,933 1,697,169 1,226,066 1,649,746 1,788,410 20,583,683
Grand Total 25,239,248 29,747,796 48,724,619 17,249,818 42,434,103 6,992,867 33,108,016 57,601,927 32,076,434 22,355,151 29,977,773 32,755,664 378,263,416